Introducing Mystic Rewards!

Your Profit Shares Are Now
Mystic Reward Points

Shop today for FREE stamps and supplies!

Great news – Now it’s easier than ever to get free stamps and supplies for your collection.

Here’s everything new about Mystic Rewards:

Don’t know your Membership Number? Find it on the bottom of your invoice.


  • The Profit Shares you’ve earned have been converted to Mystic Reward Points. You still earn 10 Reward Points (Shares) for every dollar spent at Mystic.
  • We’ll keep track of your purchases and credit Reward Points as you earn them – You won’t have to worry about losing your paper Shares, or spending time counting.
  • It’s quick and easy to shop with Reward Points online at the new
  • You can also redeem your Reward Points by phone or mail.
  • Your Reward Point balance can be viewed online anytime.
  • You’ll also receive a quarterly statement in the mail with your Points balance and special offers.

We’ve made a wide selection of great stamps and collecting supplies available for FREE through Mystic Rewards.  Click here to sign in and check your balance – you might have more Points than you think!

We’re always adding new coins and supplies to Mystic Rewards, so be sure to check back often!

Start shopping with your points today – click here.