Introducing Mystic Rewards!

Your Profit Shares Are Now
Mystic Reward Points

Shop today for FREE stamps and supplies!

Great news – Now it’s easier than ever to get free stamps and supplies for your collection.

Here’s everything new about Mystic Rewards:

Don’t know your Membership Number? Find it on the bottom of your invoice.


  • The Profit Shares you’ve earned have been converted to Mystic Reward Points. You still earn 10 Reward Points (Shares) for every dollar spent at Mystic.
  • We’ll keep track of your purchases and credit Reward Points as you earn them – You won’t have to worry about losing your paper Shares, or spending time counting.
  • It’s quick and easy to shop with Reward Points online at the new
  • You can also redeem your Reward Points by phone or mail.
  • Your Reward Point balance can be viewed online anytime.
  • You’ll also receive a quarterly statement in the mail with your Points balance and special offers.

We’ve made a wide selection of great stamps and collecting supplies available for FREE through Mystic Rewards.  Click here to sign in and check your balance – you might have more Points than you think!

We’re always adding new coins and supplies to Mystic Rewards, so be sure to check back often!