Some of the rarest stamps and covers in all of philately are right here in Mystic's inventory, and this is your chance to get one in your collection. Each of these items has a unique story about how it became the rarity it is today. Click on the one you're interested in to learn more about it. Who knows? Today could be the day your stamp collecting dreams come true...
Rare StampsRare U.S. StampsRare Covers
433 records.
  • Next
1998 Yellow Hat 'H' Rate US #3269v

1998 Yellow Hat "H" Rate

$1,250.00- $2,495.00
view now >
1847 5c Benjamin Franklin, red-brown, thin bluish wove paper, imperforate US #1

1847 5c Benjamin Franklin, red-brown, thin bluish wove paper, imperforate

$2,395.00- $4,500.00
view now >
1869 6c Washington, ultramarine US #115

1869 6c Washington, ultramarine

$3,240.00
view now >
1873-88 Bank Note Stamp Collection, Set of 7 Stamps US #157//217

1873-88 Bank Note Stamp Collection, Set of 7 Stamps

$990.00
view now >
1866 15c Lincoln, black US #77

1866 15c Lincoln, black

$1,200.00- $2,200.00
view now >
1930 Graf Zeppelins, 3 stamps US #C13-15

1930 Graf Zeppelins, 3 stamps

$3,295.00
view now >
1896 Hawaii Officials, Complete Set of 6 stamps Hawaii #HO1-6

1896 Hawaii Officials, Complete Set of 6 stamps

$1,850.00
view now >
Tax Paid U.S. Revenue stamps, 420v US #M11196

Tax Paid U.S. Revenue stamps, 420v

$995.00
view now >
1898 2c Farming in the West #286 Sheet US #MA1690

1898 2c Farming in the West #286 Sheet

$3,600.00
view now >
1851-57 3c George Washington, orange-brown, imperforate, type I US #10

1851-57 3c George Washington, orange-brown, imperforate, type I

$4,250.00
view now >
1867 30¢ Benjamin Franklin, orange US #100

1867 30¢ Benjamin Franklin, orange

$2,150.00
view now >
1867 90¢ George Washington, F-Grill, blue US #101

1867 90¢ George Washington, F-Grill, blue

$1,200.00- $2,200.00
view now >
1875 24c Washington, deep violet US #109

1875 24c Washington, deep violet

$8,500.00
view now >
1851-57 3c Washington, orange-brown, imperforate, type II US #10A

1851-57 3c Washington, orange-brown, imperforate, type II

$3,495.00
view now >
1846 10c gray black US #10X2

1846 10c gray black

$1,725.00
view now >
1851 3c Benjamin Franklin #11-E3a, Essay US #11-E3a

1851 3c Benjamin Franklin #11-E3a, Essay

$1,495.00
view now >
3¢ Washington Essay on Stiff Stamp Paper, by Bradbury, Wilkinson & Co, England US #11-E5a

3¢ Washington Essay on Stiff Stamp Paper, by Bradbury, Wilkinson & Co, England

$2,150.00
view now >
1869 Pictorials, 'short' set of 'G' grills, 6 stamps US #112-17

1869 Pictorials, "short" set of "G" grills, 6 stamps

$3,125.00
view now >
1869 3c Die on India US #114-E5

1869 3c Die on India

$1,500.00
view now >
1869 10c Shield and Eagle, yellow US #116

1869 10c Shield and Eagle, yellow

$12,850.00
view now >
1869 12c S.S. Adriatic, green US #117

1869 12c S.S. Adriatic, green

$1,250.00
view now >
1869 15c Columbus Landing, type I US #118

1869 15c Columbus Landing, type I

$2,600.00- $2,935.00
view now >
1869 15c Columbus Landing, type II US #119

1869 15c Columbus Landing, type II

$1,050.00
view now >
1845 5c Black, St. Louis Bear on Greenish Wove Paper US #11X1

1845 5c Black, St. Louis Bear on Greenish Wove Paper

$5,850.00
view now >
  • Next