Some of the rarest stamps and covers in all of philately are right here in Mystic's inventory, and this is your chance to get one in your collection. Each of these items has a unique story about how it became the rarity it is today. Click on the one you're interested in to learn more about it. Who knows? Today could be the day your stamp collecting dreams come true...
Rare StampsRare U.S. StampsRare Covers
106 records.
  • Next
1918 24c Jenny Invert US #C3a

1918 24c Jenny Invert

Call for Availability
view now >
1875 24c Washington, deep violet US #109

1875 24c Washington, deep violet

$8,500.00
view now >
1869 10c Shield and Eagle, yellow US #116

1869 10c Shield and Eagle, yellow

$12,850.00
view now >
1869 15c Columbus Landing, type I US #118

1869 15c Columbus Landing, type I

$7,395.00
view now >
1856 5c Jefferson, red brown, type I, imperforate US #12

1856 5c Jefferson, red brown, type I, imperforate

$5,450.00- $8,000.00
view now >
1869 24c Declaration of Independence without grill US #120a

1869 24c Declaration of Independence without grill

$11,000.00
view now >
1869 30c Shield, Eagle and Flags US #121

1869 30c Shield, Eagle and Flags

$14,255.00
view now >
1869 90c Lincoln, carmine and black US #122

1869 90c Lincoln, carmine and black

$7,950.00
view now >
1855 10c Washington, green, type I, imperforate US #13

1855 10c Washington, green, type I, imperforate

$5,175.00
view now >
1870-71 15c Webster, bright orange US #152

1870-71 15c Webster, bright orange

$8,750.00
view now >
1873 12c Clay, blackish violet US #162

1873 12c Clay, blackish violet

$8,525.00
view now >
1873 90c Perry, rose carmine US #166

1873 90c Perry, rose carmine

$14,000.00
view now >
1857-61 1c Franklin, perf 15 US #19

1857-61 1c Franklin, perf 15

$11,000.00
view now >
Complete Set of Dollar-Value Columbians On Registered Covers US #241-45

Complete Set of Dollar-Value Columbians On Registered Covers

$19,000.00
view now >
1894 2c Washington, carmine, unwatermarked, type II US #251

1894 2c Washington, carmine, unwatermarked, type II

$6,000.00
view now >
1857-61 3c Washington, type III US #26

1857-61 3c Washington, type III

Call for Availability
view now >
1894 $5 Marshall, unwatermarked US #263

1894 $5 Marshall, unwatermarked

$7,000.00
view now >
1898 1c Trans-Mississippi Exposition: Marquette on the Mississippi US #285

1898 1c Trans-Mississippi Exposition: Marquette on the Mississippi

Call for Availability
view now >
1898 2c Trans-Mississippi Exposition: Farming in the West US #286

1898 2c Trans-Mississippi Exposition: Farming in the West

Call for Availability
view now >
1898 8c Trans-Mississippi Exposition: Troops Guarding Train US #289

1898 8c Trans-Mississippi Exposition: Troops Guarding Train

Call for Availability
view now >
1898 10c Trans Mississippi Exposition: Hardships of Emigration US #290

1898 10c Trans Mississippi Exposition: Hardships of Emigration

Call for Availability
view now >
1901 1c Pan-American Exposition: Fast Lake Navigation US #294

1901 1c Pan-American Exposition: Fast Lake Navigation

Call for Availability
view now >
1901 2c Pan-American Exposition: Empire State Express US #295

1901 2c Pan-American Exposition: Empire State Express

Call for Availability
view now >
1901 8¢ Pan-American Exposition: Canal Locks at Sault Ste. Marie US #298

1901 8¢ Pan-American Exposition: Canal Locks at Sault Ste. Marie

Call for Availability
view now >
  • Next