What is Mystic Rewards?

You earn Rewards Points for every dollar spent with Mystic. Use your points to get stamps, coins, and collecting supplies!
Click Here to Learn More.


5421 records.
  • Next
1852 1c Franklin, blue, imperforate, type IV US #9 1852

1852 1c Franklin, blue, imperforate, type IV

Used Stamp (small flaws)
25,530 points
add to cart >
1851-57 3c Washington, orange-brown, imperforate, type II US #10A 1851-57

1851-57 3c Washington, orange-brown, imperforate, type II

Used Stamp (small flaws)
27,600 points
add to cart >
1853-55 3¢ George Washington, dull red, type II, imperf US #11A 1855

1853-55 3¢ George Washington, dull red, type II, imperf

Used Stamp (small flaws)
2,620 points
add to cart >
1861 1¢ Benjamin Franklin, blue US #63 1861

1861 1¢ Benjamin Franklin, blue

Used Stamp (small flaws)
9,110 points
add to cart >
1861-62 3c Washington, rose US #65 1861-62

1861-62 3c Washington, rose

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
19,780 points
add to cart >
1861-62 3c Washington, rose US #65 1861-62

1861-62 3c Washington, rose

Used Stamp (small flaws)
620 points
add to cart >
1861-62 30c Franklin, orange US #71 1861-62

1861-62 30c Franklin, orange

Used Stamp (small flaws)
28,950 points
add to cart >
1867 3c Washington, rose US #88 1861-1867

1867 3c Washington, rose

Used Stamp (small flaws)
4,450 points
add to cart >
1869 1c Benjamin Franklin, buff, G grill, hard wove paper, perf 12 US #112 1869

1869 1c Benjamin Franklin, buff, G grill, hard wove paper, perf 12

Used Stamp (small flaws)
23,740 points
add to cart >
1869 2c Pony Express, brown US #113 1869

1869 2c Pony Express, brown

Used Stamp(s)
23,140 points
add to cart >
1869 12c S S Adriatic, green US #117 1869

1869 12c S S Adriatic, green

Used Stamp (small flaws)
23,740 points
add to cart >
1870 3c Washington, green 'H Grill' US #136 1870

1870 3c Washington, green 'H Grill'

Used Stamp (small flaws)
5,570 points
add to cart >
1870-71 3c Washington, green US #147 1870-71

1870-71 3c Washington, green

Used Stamp (small flaws)
350 points
add to cart >
1871 7c Stanton, vermilion US #149 1871

1871 7c Stanton, vermilion

Used Stamp (small flaws)
17,200 points
add to cart >
1870-71 12c Clay, dull violet US #151 1870-71

1870-71 12c Clay, dull violet

Used Stamp (small flaws)
37,330 points
add to cart >
1870-71 24c General W. Scott, purple US #153 1870-71

1870-71 24c General W. Scott, purple

Used Stamp (small flaws)
38,930 points
add to cart >
1873 2c Jackson, brown US #157 1873

1873 2c Jackson, brown

Used Stamp (small flaws)
3,850 points
add to cart >
1873 3c Washington, green US #158 1873

1873 3c Washington, green

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
19,320 points
add to cart >
1873 6c Lincoln, dull pink US #159 1873

1873 6c Lincoln, dull pink

Used Stamp (small flaws)
580 points plus $5.50
add to cart >
1873 10c Jefferson, brown US #161 1873

1873 10c Jefferson, brown

Used Stamp (small flaws)
4,540 points
add to cart >
1873 15c Webster, yellow orange US #163 1873

1873 15c Webster, yellow orange

Used Stamp (small flaws)
26,940 points
add to cart >
1875 5c Zachary Taylor, blue US #179 1875

1875 5c Zachary Taylor, blue

Used Stamp (small flaws)
3,860 points
add to cart >
1879 1c Franklin US #182 1879

1879 1c Franklin

Used Stamp (small flaws)
1,010 points
add to cart >
1879 2c Jackson vermilion US #183 1879

1879 2c Jackson vermilion

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
17,940 points
add to cart >
1879 2c Jackson vermilion US #183 1879

1879 2c Jackson vermilion

Used Stamp (small flaws)
820 points
add to cart >
1879 6c Abraham Lincoln, pink US #186 1879

1879 6c Abraham Lincoln, pink

Used Stamp (small flaws)
4,180 points
add to cart >
1879 10c Jefferson, brown US #188 1879

1879 10c Jefferson, brown

Used Stamp (small flaws)
4,400 points
add to cart >
1879 15c Webster, red orange US #189 1879

1879 15c Webster, red orange

Used Stamp (small flaws)
4,830 points
add to cart >
1879 30c Hamilton, full black US #190 1879

1879 30c Hamilton, full black

Used Stamp (small flaws)
4,500 points plus $25.00
add to cart >
1881 1c Franklin, re-engrave US #206 1881

1881 1c Franklin, re-engrave

Used Stamp(s)
260 points
add to cart >
1882 10c Jefferson, brown US #209 1882

1882 10c Jefferson, brown

Used Stamp(s)
1,640 points
add to cart >
1883 4c Jackson, blue green US #211 1883

1883 4c Jackson, blue green

Used Stamp (small flaws)
260 points plus $5.25
add to cart >
1887 3c Washington, vermilion US #214 1887

1887 3c Washington, vermilion

Used Stamp (small flaws)
9,270 points
add to cart >
1887 3c Washington, vermilion US #214 1887

1887 3c Washington, vermilion

Used Stamp(s)
15,180 points
add to cart >
1888 4c Andrew Jackson, carmine US #215 1888

1888 4c Andrew Jackson, carmine

Used Stamp (small flaws)
4,540 points
add to cart >
1888 5c Garfield, indigo US #216 1888

1888 5c Garfield, indigo

Used Stamp(s)
3,040 points
add to cart >
1888 30c Hamilton, orange brown US #217 1888

1888 30c Hamilton, orange brown

Used Stamp (small flaws)
5,000 points plus $40.00
add to cart >
1890 2c Washington, lake US #219D 1890

1890 2c Washington, lake

Used Stamp(s)
880 points
add to cart >
1890 2c Washington Caps-both US #220c 1890

1890 2c Washington Caps-both

Used Stamp (small flaws)
4,660 points
add to cart >
1890 4c Lincoln, dark brown US #222 1890

1890 4c Lincoln, dark brown

Used Stamp(s)
990 points
add to cart >
1890 5c U S Grant, chocolate US #223 1890

1890 5c U S Grant, chocolate

Used Stamp(s)
1,110 points
add to cart >
1890 6c Garfield, brown red US #224 1890

1890 6c Garfield, brown red

Used Stamp(s)
4,970 points
add to cart >
1893 8c Sherman, lilac US #225 1893

1893 8c Sherman, lilac

Used Stamp(s)
2,870 points
add to cart >
1890 10c Webster, green US #226 1890

1890 10c Webster, green

Used Stamp(s)
830 points
add to cart >
1890 15c Henry Clay, indigo US #227 1890

1890 15c Henry Clay, indigo

Used Stamp (small flaws)
5,190 points
add to cart >
1893 3c Flagship of Columbus US #232 1893

1893 3c Flagship of Columbus

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
1,190 points plus $23.75
add to cart >
1893 3c Flagship of Columbus US #232 1893

1893 3c Flagship of Columbus

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
11,740 points
add to cart >
1893 4c Fleet of Columbus US #233 1893

1893 4c Fleet of Columbus

Used Stamp (small flaws)
1,440 points
add to cart >
  • Next