What is Mystic Rewards?

You earn Rewards Points for every dollar spent with Mystic. Use your points to get stamps, coins, and collecting supplies!
Click Here to Learn More.


135 records.
  • Next
1873 6c Lincoln, dull pink US #159 1873

1873 6c Lincoln, dull pink

Used Stamp (small flaws)
580 points plus $5.50
add to cart >
1883 4c Jackson, blue green US #211 1883

1883 4c Jackson, blue green

Used Stamp (small flaws)
260 points plus $5.25
add to cart >
1909 2c Seward perf 12 carmine US #370 1909

1909 2c Seward perf 12 carmine

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
100 points plus $8.95
add to cart >
1919 3c Victory Issue US #537 1919

1919 3c Victory Issue

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
100 points plus $8.95
add to cart >
1990-91 Fiji, 16 stamps Fiji #629-44 1990-91

1990-91 Fiji, 16 stamps

Used Canceled Stamp(s)
1,500 points plus $24.95
add to cart >
1929 2c Edison's 1st Lamp,Coil Perf 10 US #656 1929

1929 2c Edison's 1st Lamp,Coil Perf 10

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
100 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
1931 Arlington Amphitheatre 50c US #701 1931

1931 Arlington Amphitheatre 50c

Mint Stamp(s)
1,500 points plus $30.00
add to cart >
2015 Tonga Souvenir Sheet Foldable Lantern - Complete Mint Set of 3 stamps Tonga #1260-61 2015

2015 Tonga Souvenir Sheet Foldable Lantern - Complete Mint Set of 3 stamps

Mint Stamp(s)
Very Good, Never Hinged
1,500 points plus $13.95
add to cart >
1994 $5 Washington and Jackson US #2592 1994

1994 $5 Washington and Jackson

Mint Stamp(s)
990 points plus $9.50
add to cart >
1994 29c World War II US #2838 1994

1994 29c World War II

Used Single Stamp(s)
550 points plus $4.95
add to cart >
2002 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a US #3647 2002

2002 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a

Used Single Stamp(s)
100 points plus $7.95
add to cart >
2001 United We Stand Proofcard in Folder US #58769

2001 United We Stand Proofcard in Folder

First Day Cover Proofcard
500 points plus $5.00
add to cart >
2006 Return To Monticello Nickel Coin Cvr US #59770 2006

2006 Return To Monticello Nickel Coin Cvr

Coin Cover
200 points plus $15.95
add to cart >
2001 New York Story Card US #4572009 2001

2001 New York Story Card

Coin Panel
500 points plus $5.95
add to cart >
2004 1995 Doubled Die Lincoln Cent US #4592255 2004

2004 1995 Doubled Die Lincoln Cent

Coin
500 points plus $55.95
add to cart >
2006 Thomas Jefferson Coin & Stamp Set US #4597192 2006

2006 Thomas Jefferson Coin & Stamp Set

Coin
1,000 points plus $12.95
add to cart >
American National Parks P & D Series Album US #CNF5 2010-21

American National Parks P & D Series Album

250 points plus $20.00
add to cart >
CWS's 1 Volume Phoenix Worldwide Stamp Album Worldwide Stamps #DS940

CWS's 1 Volume Phoenix Worldwide Stamp Album

200 points plus $65.95
add to cart >
1-Pocket Page, Black, Package of 25 US #GS924

1-Pocket Page, Black, Package of 25

500 points plus $15.00
add to cart >
25 Different US First Day Covers US #M588

25 Different US First Day Covers

Cover Mix
1,050 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
Bhutan, 100 Stamps Bhutan #M4211

Bhutan, 100 Stamps

250 points plus $12.95
add to cart >
1970-2001 Cuba 600 Cancelled Stamps Cuba #M7033 1970-2001

1970-2001 Cuba 600 Cancelled Stamps

200 points plus $39.95
add to cart >
1970-96 Cuba Collection, 725 stamps,Used Cuba #M7370 1970-96

1970-96 Cuba Collection, 725 stamps,Used

1,000 points plus $75.95
add to cart >
Hungary, 1000v Hungary #MP1520

Hungary, 1000v

200 points plus $25.95
add to cart >
Cocos Island, 50v Cocos Island #MP2062

Cocos Island, 50v

250 points plus $19.95
add to cart >
Sweden 1983 Mint Year Set Sweden #PREM36 1983

Sweden 1983 Mint Year Set

Mint Stamp(s)
200 points plus $19.95
add to cart >
1883 4c Jackson, blue green US #211 1883

1883 4c Jackson, blue green

Used Stamp (small flaws)
6,080 points
add to cart >
1909 2c Seward perf 12 carmine US #370 1909

1909 2c Seward perf 12 carmine

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
2,880 points
add to cart >
1919 3c Victory Issue US #537 1919

1919 3c Victory Issue

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
1,330 points
add to cart >
1931 Arlington Amphitheatre 50c US #701 1931

1931 Arlington Amphitheatre 50c

Mint Stamp(s)
15,220 points
add to cart >
1994 $5 Washington and Jackson US #2592 1994

1994 $5 Washington and Jackson

Mint Stamp(s)
5,400 points
add to cart >
1994 29c World War II US #2838 1994

1994 29c World War II

Used Single Stamp(s)
1,720 points
add to cart >
2002 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a US #3647 2002

2002 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a

Used Single Stamp(s)
2,590 points
add to cart >
1928 2c Washington,carmine Type II US #634A 1928

1928 2c Washington,carmine Type II

Used Single Stamp(s)
100 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
2000 $11.75 Achievement and Exploration US #3412 2000

2000 $11.75 Achievement and Exploration

Mint Stamp(s)
2,400 points plus $25.00
add to cart >
2003 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a US #3647A 2003

2003 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a

Used Single Stamp(s)
570 points plus $5.50
add to cart >
1993 VAS Savorgnan de Brazza Silver Coin Gibraltar #4463293 1993

1993 VAS Savorgnan de Brazza Silver Coin

Coin
250 points plus $24.95
add to cart >
1945 Germany - Final Third Reich Issue - Nazi Semipostal Stamps (limit 1 per order) Germany #B292-93 1945

1945 Germany - Final Third Reich Issue - Nazi Semipostal Stamps (limit 1 per order)

Mint Stamp(s)
Very Good, Never Hinged
1,000 points plus $49.95
add to cart >
Lighthouse Mint Sheet Album, Fits oversized sheets up to 340 x 370 mm US #DS916

Lighthouse Mint Sheet Album, Fits oversized sheets up to 340 x 370 mm

500 points plus $39.95
add to cart >
Mystic's All Purpose Binder, 3-Ring, Burgundy, 11 x 11 1/2 US #ES1020

Mystic's All Purpose Binder, 3-Ring, Burgundy, 11 x 11 1/2

630 points plus $6.00
add to cart >
1-Pocket Page, Large, Clear, Package of 10 US #GS925

1-Pocket Page, Large, Clear, Package of 10

420 points plus $4.00
add to cart >
Worldwide, set of 2000 used Worldwide Stamps #M3738

Worldwide, set of 2000 used

1,000 points plus $24.95
add to cart >
SAFE Precision Mount Cutter US #SG609

SAFE Precision Mount Cutter

400 points plus $60.95
add to cart >
1928 2c Washington,carmine Type II US #634A 1928

1928 2c Washington,carmine Type II

Used Single Stamp(s)
3,070 points
add to cart >
2003 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a US #3647A 2003

2003 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a

Used Single Stamp(s)
2,100 points
add to cart >
Mystic's All Purpose Binder, 3-Ring, Burgundy, 11 x 11 1/2 US #ES1020

Mystic's All Purpose Binder, 3-Ring, Burgundy, 11 x 11 1/2

2,250 points
add to cart >
1-Pocket Page, Large, Clear, Package of 10 US #GS925

1-Pocket Page, Large, Clear, Package of 10

1,330 points
add to cart >
1888 4c Andrew Jackson, carmine US #215 1888

1888 4c Andrew Jackson, carmine

Used Stamp (small flaws)
600 points plus $6.95
add to cart >
  • Next