What is Mystic Rewards?

You earn Rewards Points for every dollar spent with Mystic. Use your points to get stamps, coins, and collecting supplies!
Click Here to Learn More.


121 records.
  • Next
1879 30c Hamilton, full black US #190 1879

1879 30c Hamilton, full black

Used Stamp (small flaws)
4,500 points plus $25.00
add to cart >
1883 4c Jackson, blue green US #211 1883

1883 4c Jackson, blue green

Used Stamp (small flaws)
260 points plus $5.25
add to cart >
1888 30c Hamilton, orange brown US #217 1888

1888 30c Hamilton, orange brown

Used Stamp (small flaws)
5,000 points plus $40.00
add to cart >
1906 1c Franklin, Imperf US #314 1906

1906 1c Franklin, Imperf

Mint Stamp(s)
Very Fine
1,000 points plus $29.95
add to cart >
1908 2c Washington, DL Wmrk US #332 1908

1908 2c Washington, DL Wmrk

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
150 points plus $3.75
add to cart >
1909 2c Seward perf 12 carmine US #370 1909

1909 2c Seward perf 12 carmine

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
100 points plus $8.95
add to cart >
1917 6c Washington, red orange US #506 1917

1917 6c Washington, red orange

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
100 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
1993 29c Hank Williams, perf 11.2 x 11.5 US #2723A 1993

1993 29c Hank Williams, perf 11.2 x 11.5

Mint Stamp(s)
630 points plus $12.50
add to cart >
2011 First-Class Forever Stamp - Disney-Pixar Films: Send a Hello US #4553-57 2011

2011 First-Class Forever Stamp - Disney-Pixar Films: Send a Hello

Mint Stamp(s)
100 points plus $7.95
add to cart >
2013 First-Class Forever Stamp - Made in America: Building a Nation US #4801 2013

2013 First-Class Forever Stamp - Made in America: Building a Nation

Mint Stamp(s)
1,310 points plus $12.50
add to cart >
1979 Moonlanding Covers Set of 6 & Facsimile US #54892 1979

1979 Moonlanding Covers Set of 6 & Facsimile

Fleetwood Commemorative Cover Set
810 points plus $5.25
add to cart >
1978 Set of 39 Commemorative Covers; 1 Cover Commemorating each of the 39 signers of the Constitution US #96200C 1978

1978 Set of 39 Commemorative Covers; 1 Cover Commemorating each of the 39 signers of the Constitution

Fleetwood Commemorative Cover Set
500 points plus $39.95
add to cart >
JFK 50c Marine Scout Snipers US #CNS40002

JFK 50c Marine Scout Snipers

Coin
250 points plus $4.95
add to cart >
JFK 50c U.S. Special Forces US #CNS40003

JFK 50c U.S. Special Forces

Coin
250 points plus $4.95
add to cart >
Vario Classic Binder and Slipcase US #ESDC4

Vario Classic Binder and Slipcase

900 points plus $35.95
add to cart >
Ultra Optix 4X Power Ultra Dome Magnifier, 2' US #LS311

Ultra Optix 4X Power Ultra Dome Magnifier, 2"

300 points plus $8.95
add to cart >
Bulgaria, 300v used Bulgaria #M3133

Bulgaria, 300v used

500 points plus $19.95
add to cart >
Bhutan, 100 Stamps Bhutan #M4211

Bhutan, 100 Stamps

250 points plus $12.95
add to cart >
Br. Antarctic Territory, 25 stamps British Antarctic Territory #M7412

Br. Antarctic Territory, 25 stamps

500 points plus $17.95
add to cart >
North Borneo & Sabah, 25v North Borneo #M8543

North Borneo & Sabah, 25v

500 points plus $8.95
add to cart >
St Vincent 50 Different Stamps St. Vincent #M12267

St Vincent 50 Different Stamps

420 points plus $4.00
add to cart >
Tokelau Islands, 50v Tokelau #MP1078

Tokelau Islands, 50v

250 points plus $29.95
add to cart >
1913 15c Parcel Post Stamp US #Q7 1913

1913 15c Parcel Post Stamp

Used Stamp(s)
200 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
Stamp Necktie: Zeppelin at Chicago Expo #C18, Black Background US #ST5

Stamp Necktie: Zeppelin at Chicago Expo #C18, Black Background

250 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
Stamp Necktie: Colombus #245, Blue Background US #ST12

Stamp Necktie: Colombus #245, Blue Background

250 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
1917 6c Washington, red orange US #506 1917

1917 6c Washington, red orange

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
1,710 points
add to cart >
1993 29c Hank Williams, perf 11.2 x 11.5 US #2723A 1993

1993 29c Hank Williams, perf 11.2 x 11.5

Mint Stamp(s)
5,000 points
add to cart >
2011 First-Class Forever Stamp - Disney-Pixar Films: Send a Hello US #4553-57 2011

2011 First-Class Forever Stamp - Disney-Pixar Films: Send a Hello

Mint Stamp(s)
1,680 points
add to cart >
2013 First-Class Forever Stamp - Made in America: Building a Nation US #4801 2013

2013 First-Class Forever Stamp - Made in America: Building a Nation

Mint Stamp(s)
4,970 points
add to cart >
Ultra Optix 4X Power Ultra Dome Magnifier, 2' US #LS311

Ultra Optix 4X Power Ultra Dome Magnifier, 2"

4,480 points
add to cart >
St Vincent 50 Different Stamps St. Vincent #M12267

St Vincent 50 Different Stamps

2,000 points
add to cart >
1913 15c Parcel Post Stamp US #Q7 1913

1913 15c Parcel Post Stamp

Used Stamp(s)
3,090 points
add to cart >
1893 3c Flagship of Columbus US #232 1893

1893 3c Flagship of Columbus

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
1,190 points plus $23.75
add to cart >
1925 6c Garfield, orange, perf 10 US #587 1925

1925 6c Garfield, orange, perf 10

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
150 points plus $7.95
add to cart >
1929 2c Edison's 1st Lamp,Coil Perf 10 US #656 1929

1929 2c Edison's 1st Lamp,Coil Perf 10

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
100 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
2015 Tonga Souvenir Sheet Foldable Lantern - Complete Mint Set of 3 stamps Tonga #1260-61 2015

2015 Tonga Souvenir Sheet Foldable Lantern - Complete Mint Set of 3 stamps

Mint Stamp(s)
Very Good, Never Hinged
1,500 points plus $13.95
add to cart >
2000 34c Lilies, bklt 11 1/2x11 3/4 s/a US #3458-61 2000

2000 34c Lilies, bklt 11 1/2x11 3/4 s/a

Mint Stamp(s)
200 points plus $25.95
add to cart >
2002 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a US #3647 2002

2002 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a

Used Stamp(s)
100 points plus $7.95
add to cart >
2005 37c Modern American Architectures US #3910 2005

2005 37c Modern American Architectures

Mint Stamp(s)
200 points plus $10.95
add to cart >
2013 First-Class Forever Stamp - La Florida US #4750-53 2013

2013 First-Class Forever Stamp - La Florida

Mint Stamp(s)
100 points plus $5.95
add to cart >
1945 Germany - Final Third Reich Issue - Nazi Semipostal Stamps (limit 1 per order) Germany #B292-93 1945

1945 Germany - Final Third Reich Issue - Nazi Semipostal Stamps (limit 1 per order)

Mint Stamp(s)
Very Good, Never Hinged
1,000 points plus $49.95
add to cart >
25 Different US First Day Covers US #M588

25 Different US First Day Covers

Cover Mix
1,050 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
Worldwide 1/4lb Off Paper Worldwide Stamps #M2056

Worldwide 1/4lb Off Paper

500 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
1893 3c Flagship of Columbus US #232 1893

1893 3c Flagship of Columbus

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
11,740 points
add to cart >
1925 6c Garfield, orange, perf 10 US #587 1925

1925 6c Garfield, orange, perf 10

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
2,600 points
add to cart >
2000 34c Lilies, bklt 11 1/2x11 3/4 s/a US #3458-61 2000

2000 34c Lilies, bklt 11 1/2x11 3/4 s/a

Mint Stamp(s)
5,180 points
add to cart >
2002 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a US #3647 2002

2002 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a

Used Stamp(s)
2,590 points
add to cart >
2005 37c Modern American Architectures US #3910 2005

2005 37c Modern American Architectures

Mint Stamp(s)
2,570 points
add to cart >
  • Next