What is Mystic Rewards?

You earn Rewards Points for every dollar spent with Mystic. Use your points to get stamps, coins, and collecting supplies!
Click Here to Learn More.


258 records.
  • Next
1873 6c Lincoln, dull pink US #159 1873

1873 6c Lincoln, dull pink

Used Stamp (small flaws)
580 points plus $5.50
add to cart >
1879 30c Hamilton, full black US #190 1879

1879 30c Hamilton, full black

Used Stamp (small flaws)
4,500 points plus $25.00
add to cart >
1883 4c Jackson, blue green US #211 1883

1883 4c Jackson, blue green

Used Stamp (small flaws)
260 points plus $5.25
add to cart >
1888 30c Hamilton, orange brown US #217 1888

1888 30c Hamilton, orange brown

Used Stamp (small flaws)
5,000 points plus $40.00
add to cart >
1893 3c Flagship of Columbus US #232 1893

1893 3c Flagship of Columbus

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
1,190 points plus $23.75
add to cart >
1906 1c Franklin, Imperf US #314 1906

1906 1c Franklin, Imperf

Mint Stamp(s)
Very Fine
1,000 points plus $29.95
add to cart >
1908 2c Washington, DL Wmrk US #332 1908

1908 2c Washington, DL Wmrk

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
150 points plus $3.75
add to cart >
1909 2c Seward perf 12 carmine US #370 1909

1909 2c Seward perf 12 carmine

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
100 points plus $8.95
add to cart >
1917 6c Washington, red orange US #506 1917

1917 6c Washington, red orange

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
100 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
1919 3c Victory Issue US #537 1919

1919 3c Victory Issue

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
100 points plus $8.95
add to cart >
1923 $2 Capitol, deep blue US #572 1923

1923 $2 Capitol, deep blue

Used Stamp(s)
230 points plus $4.50
add to cart >
1925 6c Garfield, orange, perf 10 US #587 1925

1925 6c Garfield, orange, perf 10

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
150 points plus $7.95
add to cart >
1923 2c Harding, black, imperf US #611 1923

1923 2c Harding, black, imperf

Mint Stamp(s)
100 points plus $8.95
add to cart >
1924 5c Monument at Mayport, Florida US #616 1924

1924 5c Monument at Mayport, Florida

Mint Stamp(s)
2,630 points plus $25.00
add to cart >
1925 2c 'Birth of Liberty' US #618 1925

1925 2c "Birth of Liberty"

Mint Stamp(s)
630 points plus $6.50
add to cart >
1928 2c Washington,carmine Type II US #634A 1928

1928 2c Washington,carmine Type II

Used Stamp(s)
100 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
1929 2c Edison's 1st Lamp,Coil Perf 10 US #656 1929

1929 2c Edison's 1st Lamp,Coil Perf 10

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
100 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
1929 2c Edison's 1st Lamp,Coil Perf 10 US #656 1929

1929 2c Edison's 1st Lamp,Coil Perf 10

Mint Stamp(s)
490 points plus $9.75
add to cart >
1929 T Roosevelt 5c deep blue US #674 1929

1929 T Roosevelt 5c deep blue

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
200 points plus $19.95
add to cart >
1931 Arlington Amphitheatre 50c US #701 1931

1931 Arlington Amphitheatre 50c

Mint Stamp(s)
1,500 points plus $30.00
add to cart >
1934 3c Byrd Antarctic Expedition US #735 1934

1934 3c Byrd Antarctic Expedition

Mint Stamp(s)
1,180 points plus $11.25
add to cart >
1934 9c Glacier National Park, Montana US #748 1934

1934 9c Glacier National Park, Montana

Mint Stamp(s)
100 points plus $2.50
add to cart >
1934 10c Gr. Smoky Mtns., N. Carolina US #749 1934

1934 10c Gr. Smoky Mtns., N. Carolina

Mint Stamp(s)
250 points plus $5.00
add to cart >
1934 3c Mt. Rainier, Washington US #750 1934

1934 3c Mt. Rainier, Washington

Mint Stamp(s)
1,480 points plus $29.50
add to cart >
1934 1c Yosemite, California US #751 1934

1934 1c Yosemite, California

Unused Stamp (small flaws)
200 points plus $9.95
add to cart >
1940-2000 'Honoring Those Who Served' US #900//3396 1940-2000

1940-2000 "Honoring Those Who Served"

Mint Stamp(s)
1,200 points plus $11.50
add to cart >
1956 Liberty Series - $5 Alexander Hamilton US #1053 1956

1956 Liberty Series - $5 Alexander Hamilton

Classic First Day Cover
4,000 points plus $25.00
add to cart >
1956 Liberty Series - $5 Alexander Hamilton US #1053 1956

1956 Liberty Series - $5 Alexander Hamilton

Used Stamp (small flaws)
500 points plus $3.00
add to cart >
1976 13c State Flags US #1633-82 1976

1976 13c State Flags

Fleetwood First Day Cover Set
2,600 points plus $119.95
add to cart >
1982 20c State Birds and Flowers US #1953-2002 1982

1982 20c State Birds and Flowers

Fleetwood First Day Cover Set
3,000 points plus $129.95
add to cart >
1983 20c Balloons US #2032-35 1983

1983 20c Balloons

Mint Stamp(s)
100 points plus $2.50
add to cart >
1991 $14.00 International Express Mail US #2542 1991

1991 $14.00 International Express Mail

Used Stamp(s)
150 points plus $3.00
add to cart >
1994 $5 Washington and Jackson US #2592 1994

1994 $5 Washington and Jackson

Mint Stamp(s)
990 points plus $9.50
add to cart >
1992 29c Wildflowers US #2647-96 1992

1992 29c Wildflowers

Fleetwood First Day Cover Set
2,600 points plus $119.95
add to cart >
1993 29c Hank Williams, perf 11.2 x 11.5 US #2723A 1993

1993 29c Hank Williams, perf 11.2 x 11.5

Mint Stamp(s)
630 points plus $12.50
add to cart >
1997 $3 Mars Pathfinder US #3178 1997

1997 $3 Mars Pathfinder

Mint Stamp(s)
550 points plus $5.25
add to cart >
1998 32c Sylvester & Tweety Imperf Sheet US #3205 1998

1998 32c Sylvester & Tweety Imperf Sheet

Mint Stamp(s)
280 points plus $5.75
add to cart >
1998 1c - $2 Trans-Mississippi US #3209 1998

1998 1c - $2 Trans-Mississippi

Used Stamp(s)
100 points plus $5.00
add to cart >
1999 33c Four Fruit Berries bklt. s/a US #3298-3301 1999

1999 33c Four Fruit Berries bklt. s/a

Mint Stamp(s)
130 points plus $2.75
add to cart >
2000 34c Lilies, bklt 11 1/2x11 3/4 s/a US #3458-61 2000

2000 34c Lilies, bklt 11 1/2x11 3/4 s/a

Mint Stamp(s)
200 points plus $25.95
add to cart >
2002 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a US #3647 2002

2002 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a

Used Stamp(s)
100 points plus $7.95
add to cart >
2003 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a US #3647A 2003

2003 $3.85 Jefferson Memorial, s/a

Used Stamp(s)
570 points plus $5.50
add to cart >
2002 37c Greetings From America, s/a US #3696-3745 2002

2002 37c Greetings From America, s/a

Mint Stamp(s)
1,370 points plus $27.50
add to cart >
2004 37c Art of American Indian US #3873 2004

2004 37c Art of American Indian

Mint Stamp(s)
250 points plus $10.00
add to cart >
2004 37c Cloudscapes US #3878 2004

2004 37c Cloudscapes

Mint Stamp(s)
250 points plus $15.95
add to cart >
2005 37c Modern American Architectures US #3910 2005

2005 37c Modern American Architectures

Mint Stamp(s)
200 points plus $10.95
add to cart >
2005 37c Jim Henson & Muppets US #3944 2005

2005 37c Jim Henson & Muppets

Mint Stamp(s)
350 points plus $7.00
add to cart >
2006 39c American Diplomats US #4076 2006

2006 39c American Diplomats

Mint Stamp(s)
100 points plus $6.95
add to cart >
  • Next