You earn Rewards Points for every dollar spent with Mystic. Use your points to get stamps, coins, and collecting supplies! Click Here to Learn More.
2001 NY St. Quarter - Hologram Coin
1984 20c Small Business USA Envelope Fleetwood First Day Cover
1923 9c Jefferson, rose Used Stamp (small flaws)
1924 10c Monroe, orange, coil Mint Stamp(s)
1929 9c Jefferson, light rose, Kansas-Nebraska overprints Unused Stamp (small flaws)
1937 5c Army and Navy: Seal of U.S. Naval Academy Unused Stamp (small flaws)
2002 37c Contemporary Christmas: Snowmen, large booklet Mint Stamp(s)
1882 5c Garfield, yellow brown Used Stamp (small flaws)
1909 2c Seward, carmine, perf 12 Used Stamp (small flaws)
1912 2c Washington, carmine Used Stamp (small flaws)
1924 1c Huguenot-Walloon Tercentenary: Ship Nieu Nederland Used Single Stamp(s)
1935 5c National Parks: Yellowstone, imperf, no gum Mint Stamp(s)
1974 10c Robert Frost First Day Cover Proofcard
1994 29c World War II Mint Stamp(s)
1998 32c Sylvester & Tweety Imperf Pane of 1 Mint Stamp(s)
2002 $13.65 U.S. Capitol Dome, Express Mail Mint Stamp(s)
2003 25c Eagle, Non Denomination, Coil Mint Stamp(s)
1965 Inauguration C. Pres. Johnson Special Event Cover or Card
1863 2c Jackson, black Used Stamp (small flaws)
1913 1c Panama-Pacific Exposition: Balboa, green, perf 12 Used Single Stamp(s)
1917 Washington violet, perf 10, Type I Used Stamp (small flaws)
1917 11c Franklin, light green Used Stamp (small flaws)
1920 $2 Franklin, carmine black Used Single Stamp(s)
1934 1c Yosemite, imperf single Used Single Stamp(s)
1935 6c National Parks: Crater Lake, imperf, no gum Mint Stamp(s)
1935 7c National Parks: Acadia, imperf, no gum Mint Stamp(s)
1935 8c National Parks: Zion, imperf, no gum Mint Stamp(s)
1935 9c National Parks: Glacier National Park, imperf, no gum Mint Stamp(s)
1935 10c National Parks: Great Smoky Mountains, imperf, no gum Mint Stamp(s)
1994 29c Blues and Jazz Singers: Muddy Waters Mint Stamp(s)
1994 32c G-rate Old Glory, red "G" Mint Stamp(s)
2002 37c Contemporary Christmas: Snowmen, small booklet Mint Stamp(s)
2004 37c Art of the American Indian Mint Stamp(s)
1893 4c Columbian Commemorative: Fleet of Columbus Used Stamp (small flaws)
1895 4c Lincoln, dark brown, double line watermark Used Stamp (small flaws)
1898 1c Trans-Mississippi Exposition: Marquette on the Mississippi Used Stamp (small flaws)
1928 2c Valley Forge Issue: Washington at Prayer Unused Stamp (small flaws)
1929 2c Edison's First Lamp, coil perf 10 Used Stamp (small flaws)
1934 6c National Parks: Crater Lake, Oregon Mint Stamp(s)
1934 8c National Parks: Zion, Utah Mint Stamp(s)
1935 4c National Parks: Mesa Verde, imperf, no gum Mint Stamp(s)
1999 33c Celebrate the Century: 1940s Mint Stamp(s)
1999 33c Tropical Flowers Mint Stamp(s)
2000 33c Legends of Baseball Mint Stamp(s)
2000 34c Lilies, 11.5 x 11.75 perf, booklet stamps Mint Stamp(s)
2004 37c Cloudscapes Mint Stamp(s)
2004 37c Contemporary Christmas: Santa Ornaments, booklet stamps Mint Stamp(s)
2006 39c Contemporary Christmas: Holiday Snowflakes, ATM booklet Mint Stamp(s)