You earn Rewards Points for every dollar spent with Mystic. Use your points to get stamps, coins, and collecting supplies! Click Here to Learn More.
1967 $1 Prominent Americans: Eugene O'Neill Classic First Day Cover
1974 10c Universal Postal Union Fleetwood First Day Cover Set
1985 22c Seashells Fleetwood First Day Cover Set
1997 $3 Mars Pathfinder Colorano Silk First Day Cover
1960 7c Jet Airliner,bklt pane of 6 Classic First Day Cover
2001 NY St. Quarter - Hologram Coin
Elvis "Stuck on You" Colorized Qtr. Coin
Muhammad Ali Kt Qtr Head Down Left Hand Coin
Muhammad Ali Kt Qtr With Boxing Headset, Coin
Muhammad Ali Kt Qtr Arms Raised and Coin
2000 SC State Quarter Gold Plate Coin
1997 Liberia $5 "Lady Spencer" Coin
The Heritage Wildlife US Stamp Collection Binder
The Royal Wedding, Diana the Princess of Wales Cupronickel Coin Coin
2016 $450 President Donald Trump s/s
2013 Tuvalu Royal Baby Stamps
2016 $12 Andriyan Nikolayev, Russian Cosmonauts sheet of 4
1898 4c Trans-Mississippi Exposition: Indian Hunting Buffalo Used Stamp (small flaws)
1935 10c National Parks: Great Smoky Mountains, imperf, no gum Mint Stamp(s)
1969 6c Professional Baseball Classic First Day Cover
Elvis 30th Anniversary Tribute on Mississippi Quarter Coin
150 Flags of the World Labels
1875 2c Andrew Jackson, vermilion Used Stamp (small flaws)
1895 15c Clay, dark blue, double line watermark Used Stamp (small flaws)
1912 2c Washington, carmine Used Stamp (small flaws)
1914 9c Franklin, salmon red, single line watermark Used Stamp (small flaws)
1946 3c US Armed Forces: Merchant Marine Classic First Day Cover
1983 20c George "Babe Ruth" Herman Classic First Day Cover
Germany 10 Reichspfennig Coin
1901 8¢ Pan-American Exposition: Canal Locks at Sault Ste. Marie Used Stamp (small flaws)
1929 1c Franklin, green, Kansas-Nebraska overprints Mint Stamp(s)
1994 $5 Washington and Jackson Mint Stamp(s)
2005 37c Distinguished Marines Mint Stamp(s)
2013 First-Class Forever Stamp - Music Icons: Johnny Cash Fleetwood First Day Cover
1891 1c Postage Due Stamp Used Stamp (small flaws)
1895 5c Postage Due Stamp Used Stamp (small flaws)
1883 4c Jackson, blue green Used Stamp (small flaws)
1893 6c Columbian Commemorative: Columbus Welcomed at Barcelona Used Stamp (small flaws)
1904 5c William McKinley, dark blue Used Stamp (small flaws)
1907 5c Jamestown Commemorative: Pocahontas, blue Used Stamp (small flaws)
1981 18c Battles of Yorktown and Virginia Mint Stamp(s)
1992 29c Summer Olympics Mint Stamp(s)
1992 29c World War II Mint Stamp(s)
1998 32c Celebrate the Century: 1920s Mint Stamp(s)
1999 33c Celebrate the Century: 1950s Mint Stamp(s)
1999 33c Celebrate the Century: 1960s Mint Stamp(s)
1918 16c Curtiss Jenny, green Used Stamp (small flaws)