Our Gift to You
Get Mystic’s 2026 “A Year in Stamps” calendar FREE with any order of $100 or more. Offer available while supplies last. Full-color stamp images highlight historic and postal events each month.
Remember These Holiday Helpers?
Add Christmas Seals to your collection that helped fund major health initiatives for decades. Their festive artwork and purpose make them holiday favorites.
Make Holiday Shopping Easy
Don't leave your loved ones guessing this season—tell them exactly what you want! A Mystic Stamp Gift Card lets you choose the perfect additions to your collection, while they get the joy of giving a gift you'll truly love.
Explore Our New Magnifier Options
Discover new magnifier choices designed to give you an even closer look at your stamps. Each offers clear, comfortable viewing to help you enjoy the fine details that make collecting so rewarding.
Are These Stamps in Your Collection?
The Series of 1902-03 was the first series completely designed by the Bureau of Engraving and Printing. And it included the first US stamp to picture an American woman.
Bring a Little Christmas to Your Collection with Santa Stamps
Santa stamps bring the warmth and wonder of Christmas to life in miniature works of art. Each issue features its own creative interpretation of Santa—whether he’s preparing toys, delivering gifts, or sharing a joyful holiday moment.
These Christmas stamps highlight the traditions, colors, and storytelling that make the season so meaningful, giving collectors a chance to enjoy the festive spirit through detailed designs.
We've created a special collection of 26 Santa stamps - click below to get yours.
Featured Products
Save Up To 15%
Own U.S. Error Stamps and their Non-Error Counterparts
If you want scarce and unusual US error stamps (and their non-error counterparts), we know you’re going to feel right at home as a member of our US Error Stamp Collectors’ Club.
Start with the first shipment of the 1992 29¢ Flag Over White House imperf error pair (and regular-issue stamp) for just $10 plus FREE shipping – 50% off the regular price
We waited 20 years to show you
these "Baby Zepps" Airmail stamps!
Watch our new video to discover why these "Baby Zepps" Airmail stamps are so special! Watch Here
Stay Social
Most Orders Ship
within 1 Business Day
90 Day Return Policy
Satisfaction Guaranteed
Earn Reward Points
for FREE Stamps & More